After learning Paige can't be more than 25 years old, Lucy speculates to Kevin that she's an impostor, but he accuses her of being jealous. She then contacts Victor with her suspicions. Eve suggests to Ian and Chris that she fix up Amy with Chris. Alison reads in Rafe's journal that he loves her, then she and Rafe decide they can't be friends. Ali goes home to Jamal, but thinks of Rafe. Paige and Amy are skeptical of Casey's claims that another one like them is in town. They go to the Recovery Room and, after seeing Rafe, the women vow not to leave Earth before finishing what they came to do.