Lucy shares Victor's information on Paige with Kevin, who is amazed that Paige's expired passport reveals she still looks the same. Karen suggests moving in with Frank to keep an eye on a missing Casey. Worried when Amy doesn't show up for work, Ian calls her parents and learns she's been missing for 3 years. After Rafe tells Casey, Paige and Amy he's taking them back to Heaven, the women share their stories. Paige died after a car accident on her way to seek closure with Kevin, Casey died of an overdose and Amy was shot by a man who conned her for her money. A flash of light make the four of them disappear.