Valerie is shot during her struggle with Jamal and rushed to the hospital, where she's pronounced dead. Ed won't reveal who'll fill the ""5th chair"" but tells Casey, Paige, Amy and Rafe they must help that person cross over. Gabriela defends Ricky when Ian accuses him of being behind Amy's disappearance. Amy, Casey and Paige return to Earth where Casey encounters Frank, whom she fears will die. Amy accuses Paige of wanting Kevin to die. Amy evades Ian's questions and Kevin is surprised by Paige's return. After telling Rafe that Valerie's not the ""5th chair,"" Ed gives him the choice to return to Alison who's in trouble.