Casey pulls away from Ricky, fearing he might be the one who dies if he gets close to her. She tels him she has no future. Alison, Jack, Jamal and Livvie search for Jamal and Rafe fears Jamal might be the one to die. Jack then learns Jamal was at a bar. Alison calls Rafe on his feelings for her and tells him she can't return his affections because she loves Jamal. She returns home to find Jamal, who tells her they must pay for Valerie's death. Lucy returns home, but Paige doesn't know where Kevin is. Sensing something's wrong, Lucy finds Kevin frozen in the snow, but Paige hesitates to call an ambulance.